The Original NY Style Pizza broomfield colorado - Broomfield, Colorado

Edbie

I have never left a rating for a place before. But after experiencing this food. I needed to say something. The mom and pop style of the place is nostalgic and endearing. I want to come back any time I am around.

David L.

Nice little place. Reminds me of old hole in the wall place. Pizza delivery and then a small dining area. The food was good. Lasagna tasted good, but not necessarily like classic lasagna. Garlic bread was nice. Meal was overall good, but i was hoping for that special hole in the wall place with great food. They're hard to find. Could have used a faster refill. Better than 'the garden' for sure, but it did not quite live up to my craving for real classic lasagna (I grew up in a small town with a lot of Italians and real old world meals).

John D.

The only place I have found near me that provides a good pizza. There are a few other good pizza places but not near me. Having grown up in NY I know good pizza when I eat one. This gets a very good grade. I also like their eggplant parm, very tasty. I do wish they would paint and update a little bit so it is a nicer experience.

Nicole R.

Honestly great place. The atmosphere was truly welcoming and the service was outstanding. Their pizza truly gives the essence of a slice from NY. Fell in love with their garlic bread too and their food overall is to die for😻😻! 100% recommend !

Carrie T.

I'm from Illinois. A friend of the owners highly recommended that I try the food here when I came to Colorado to visit my mom. I said sure and offered to write a review.

That was in June 2022 and my review is long overdue! 😊

The atmosphere is amazing! You step inside and you feel like you have been transported to another place entirely! (I ❤️ New York!) It is a quaint family-owned, mom-and-pop type restaurant. The main room features a huge oven that they use to cook your food! There are some arcade games and signage that make it welcoming and unique.

The side room appears to be set up for fine dining in the evening, with a variety of wines available.

When we were there, it seemed like lunch was set up more for a grab-and-go type experience. We hit the end of lunch, but the family was gracious enough to let us sit at a table to enjoy our meal.

It was a delightful experience! I had the Stromboli lunch special. It was excellent! I had never had Stromboli with sauce on the side for dipping. Super yummy!

As we left, I also noticed fresh produce and seasonings being grown right outside the door in planters. What a great idea to keep meals fresh!

In my opinion, they would have excellent results if they were to do a food truck. Set it up with those select lunch menu items for a grab-and-go type meal!

It's a bit out of a drive, but I look forward to returning the next time I'm in Colorado! My mom feels better when she eats gluten-free, so I think next time we will plan to get the gluten-free pizza!

*The menu and some information may be out-of-date due to the delay in posting this review.*

Dan C.

As a pizza nerd, I really liked it. A little too thick of crust but it held its own. The sauce was fantastic. I wasn’t a huge fan of the sausage, but others seem to love it. I’m a pinch guy.

The cheese bread is easily worth the $7. Tasty and the dipping sauce, which I assume is the spaghetti sauce, is so good. I could eat that up all day. Will try the ghetti next time.

Cara B.

Love a small business that supports their community!! We placed a takeout order for a fundraiser they had. The pizza and sandwiches were amazing! We will be back. Thank you for supporting high school baseball.

Victor C.

I love this place! The staff is great, there's a pleasant atmosphere, and as a connoisseur of pizza. They serve THE best pizza! The dough is crispy and the cheese is gooey. I don't get to eat here as often as I'd like, but whenever I do, the experience is always great. And if you want a delicious yet outrageous pizza. Ask for the "Mike Hogan" Pizza, just a disclaimer it's about a $40+ pizza and also some employees might know what you are talking about some might not.