The Milk Pail - Water Mill, New York

The Milk Pail: A Must-Visit Destination on Long Island

The Milk Pail is a charming destination located at 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, offering a unique blend of market and tourist attractions that make it a must-visit spot on Long Island. With its beautiful location and diverse range of products, it's no wonder this small business has gained a loyal following.

The Milk Pail has 210 reviews on Google My Business, with an average rating of 4.5/5, showcasing its commitment to customer satisfaction. Visitors rave about the farm's picturesque setting and the wide variety of products available, including fresh produce, jams, and local specialties.

Specialties and Features

The Milk Pail is known for its exceptional apples and jams, making it a popular destination for those seeking a sweet treat. The farm also offers a range of onsite services, including wheelchair accessibility and NFC mobile payments, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the experience.

Some of the standout features of The Milk Pail include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot
• Market with a variety of local products
• Onsite services for added convenience

Reviews and Recommendations

Visitors praise The Milk Pail for its beautiful location and wide range of products, making it a great stop for families, couples, and individuals alike. The farm's commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in its high rating, and the quick and easy parking make it an ideal destination for a quick visit.

Some reviewers have noted that the maine candy in the shape of lobsters is a highlight of their visit, with many comparing it favorably to Swedish fish. The dog biscuits and apple cider donuts are also popular among visitors.

Plan Your Visit

For those looking to explore the beautiful scenery and sample the local produce, The Milk Pail is an excellent choice. With its wheelchair accessible facilities and convenient onsite parking, it's easy to plan a visit to this charming destination.

Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience The Milk Pail's unique blend of market and tourist attractions. Visit their website for more information and to plan your trip today

👍 Reviews of The Milk Pail

Alfred S.

5/5

We were looking for a place to get some apples and jams before heading back home and found this gem.

Lish A.

5/5

I have been coming here for years. Best apple picking orchard on Long Island!! Location is as beautiful as the farm. You must make a visit here soon 🍎😍

Aaliyah K.

5/5

Great cute little market type of place. We got dog biscuits, apple cider donuts, apple cider and this maine candy in the shape of lobsters, similar to Swedish fish but 2x better. Truly loved it. It was a quick stop on the way home from Montauk

Bonnie G.

1/5

Stopped in and purchased a small bag of their lemon crinkle cookies , they were totally stale, old, and for $10, for a few cookies, I’d expect them to be fresh. Ironically the bag says fresh market. Yea not so much. Garbage!

Sarah H.

5/5

I am a regular customer, I go in every weekend for cider and sweeties and apples. It is a bright spot in my life. Everyone is so kind and happy, go the extra mile in taking care of you. Jen and Amy are the best. The other ladies are too. Thank you so much. I recommend highly. 100 points. ❤️❤️❤️

Moneshwar B.

5/5

This place and the people who works here are awesome...we bring the kids every year for apple picking... We love this place.

will T.

5/5

Best peach pie I had, so delicious soft cookies, and top off with coffee smoothie.

Richard M.

5/5

Great selection of real local food and produce. Wonderful staff.