Supreme Italian Market - Staten Island, New York

Supreme Italian Market - A Delightful Gourmet Experience

Located at 645 Rossville Ave, Staten Island, NY 10309, Supreme Italian Market is a premier destination for food enthusiasts seeking high-quality Italian products and gourmet items. With a phone number of 79834473, and a website at supremeitalianmarket.com, this establishment has quickly become a go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike.

Specialties: At Supreme Italian Market, customers can expect a wide array of specialties, including a butcher shop, catering services, a deli, and an Italian grocery store. The market prides itself on offering a curated selection of gourmet products that cater to both everyday needs and special occasions.

Other Points of Interest: In addition to its exceptional range of products, Supreme Italian Market offers several conveniences for its customers. The market is wheelchair accessible, provides delivery options, and offers in-store shopping experiences. They also cater to various events and offer quick visit options for those in a hurry. Payment methods accepted include credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments, SNAP/EBT, and credit cards.

Opinions: Supreme Italian Market has garnered a total of 26 reviews on Google My Business, showcasing its popularity and the diverse opinions of its clientele. The establishment maintains an average rating of 3.7/5, indicating a generally positive reception from patrons who appreciate the market's offerings and atmosphere.

Supreme Italian Market stands out in the competitive world of gourmet grocery stores and Italian food markets. Its commitment to providing a diverse range of high-quality products, coupled with exceptional customer service and a welcoming atmosphere, sets it apart from its competitors. For those seeking an authentic Italian grocery experience in Staten Island, Supreme Italian Market is undoubtedly a top choice.

👍 Reviews of Supreme Italian Market

Jana A.

1/5

Stopped in to grab fresh mozzarella and wound up picking up some other items. What a mistake. For starters, the fresh Mozz was the saltiest Mozz I have ever tasted. It was inedible and we bought two of them. Waste. We picked up some rice balls and a Sicilian rice ball and again rice balls were so salty and inedible and Sicilian was OLD and disgusting. Two cold salads one orichette with sausage - DISGUSTING and the orzo salad was rancid. I’m so disappointed as they used to be very good. What a waste of $80.

J. S.

1/5

I decided to check out a nearby Italian deli and explore their offerings. I was craving a sandwich. However, upon biting into it, I was disappointed to find that the bread was stale and the roast beef and eggplant were dry and flavorless. It turned out to be the worst sandwich I had ever tasted. I ended up tossing it out the window for the birds to feast on, as I knew there were much better options available in the vicinity.

Nitebeat

1/5

Meh! Personally, I liked it better when it was Christophers. Also, a recent purchase from Supreme left myself and the misses driving the porcelain bus for the better part of two days - not good! In addition, a surcharge is added to your tab if you do not pay with cash. Further, when you check out, you are not offered a bag to place your purchases in - you have to ask - otherwise I guess they expect you to just pile everything onto your arms and walk out! So much for customer SERVICE! A better more established choice is Pastosa on Richmond Avenue - a plethora of good homemade food, selections and more selections and same price cash or credit. There's usually a line to get in / check out - that speaks volumes!

M T.

1/5

This place is the absolute worst. Came in to order two of the same sandwich and after waiting for the kid to make them for 30 minutes then drive home, I find that both are practically just bread and chicken with none of the topping I asked for. Don’t waste your time or money at this dump

Molivo O.

4/5

I was in the neighborhood so I stopped in because they have pretty good reviews, their home made dishes are very good and portions are very good, my dad used to go into places like this and spend more than he had to. His eyes were bigger than his head. But the food was good.

Mik M.

5/5

Absolutely WONDERFUL addition to the Rossville parking lot-O-rama of stress. Very clean store, awesome staff, and the food is just the TRUTH. The butchers are very accommodating - there were no steak pinwheels one day, but the butcher said if I call up early he would make them for us. The filet mignon are absolutely insane. The cheese stuffed red peppers are so sweet and succulent I lick my fingers after each one I pop into my mouth. The burgers are also incredible....honestly every single cut of meat is top tier. A little on the expensive side but you get what you pay for, and nothing like supporting our Staten Island friends. I love this store and YOU WILL TOO!!!!!!

Arthur B.

5/5

Outstanding NYC deli. They were recommended by Joseph the proprietor of Little Italy Gourmet. They're always careful listeners. They're are also the GoTo team for preparing a party.🫶

Razor S.

4/5

Great little store, support a local business. The Sunday meatballs are delicious, fried chicken cutlets were on the dry side.