Settler's Select - Le Roy, New York

Settler's Select: A Delightful Dining Experience in Le Roy, NY

Settler's Select is a charming Italian restaurant located at 37 Main St, Le Roy, NY 14482, United States. With a phone number of 5855025282, this establishment offers a delightful dining experience to its patrons. The restaurant specializes in Italian cuisine and is known for its delicious dishes, friendly service, and cozy ambiance.

Specialties and Services

• Restaurant
• Italian restaurant

In addition to its specialties, Settler's Select provides various services to cater to different preferences and needs. These include:

• Takeaway
• Dine-in
• Delivery
• Fast service
• Lunch
• Dinner
• Solo dining
• Wheelchair-accessible car park
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance
• Wheelchair-accessible seating
• Wheelchair-accessible toilet
• Alcohol
• Beer
• Cocktails
• Coffee
• Comfort food
• Quick bite
• Spirits
• Wine
• Breakfast
• Brunch
• Catering
• Dessert
• Seating
• Bar on site
• Toilet
• Casual
• Cosy
• Groups
• Tourists
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• Good for kids
• High chairs
• Kids' menu
• Free of charge street parking
• Free parking lot
• On-site parking

Opinions and Reviews

Settler's Select has received 115 reviews on Google My Business, with an average rating of 3.9/5. Customers appreciate the tasty Italian cuisine, cozy atmosphere, and friendly service. However, some patrons have mentioned that the prices are on the higher side, and the service can be a bit spotty at times.

One satisfied customer mentioned, "Was a nice experience for the lady and I stopped in for brunch. Food was very tasty. And also got a mimosa each. I went with the apple cider and she went traditional. Very refreshing. The fried green tomatoes eggs benedict she went with the three little pigs. Home fries are absolutely on point Definitely have to stop in again and try out some other things." Another reviewer stated, "Great new little place in LeRoy NY. Food was a little pricy but very tasty. Service was ok but a bit spotty. For some reason the chef salted the heck out of my fries."

👍 Reviews of Settler's Select

Stephen C.

5/5

Was a nice experience for the lady and I stopped in for brunch. Food was very tasty. And also got a mimosa each. I went with the apple cider and she went traditional. Very refreshing. The fried green tomatoes eggs benedict she went with the three little pigs. Home fries are absolutely on point! Definitely have to stop in again and try out some other things.

Don W.

5/5

Great new little place in LeRoy NY
Food was a little pricy but very tasty. Service was ok but a bit spotty. For some reason the chef salted the heck out of my fries.

Connor C.

5/5

The food and atmosphere were great! Very relaxing, our waitress was very attentive. We had the strip steak and chicken salad sandwich.
I would highly recommend!

Elijah V.

5/5

Went for lunch, and this place was amazing! The food was hot and fresh, with a great variety of options on the menu. Our server was very friendly, and she was handling everything on her own! I ordered a chicken sandwich, and the sauce was delicious. It was a huge sandwich for what I’d say was a very reasonable price. Everything tasted homemade, except for the chips, which seemed like they were from a bag—but they were still good, and they also gave us fries. The food came out fairly quickly, which was a plus. Overall, Settler’s Select was delicious, and I highly recommend anyone to go check it out. I really hope this place sticks around!

J C.

5/5

Settler's Select breaths new life into historic building. Food is fantastic and service is friendly! Tried the BLT with fried green tomatoes. Divine. Poutine? Top notch. Lots of food with unique twists along with standard fare. Love the refreshed atmosphere inside! Will be back to try breakfast soon!

tom G.

4/5

Fish fry had pool of oil under it disgusting. Drained 1/4 cup of water from pasta side dish disgusting. No fries available no coleslaw no dinner rolls what a joke owner must not eat there!

Mikhayla W.

5/5

Me and my family ate here tonight- our waitress was amazing also our food was delicious. We had the chicken tenders & fries, Reuben, and settlers burger and all three were very delicious. We will be coming back ☺️

Christina A.

1/5

Omelet was good,but the pancakes tasted like cardboard with salt. Food was expensive. Definitely not worth the hype.