Mikey's Pizza - Crested Butte, Colorado

Okay, here’s a detailed description of Mikey’s Pizza, crafted with a formal and approachable tone, designed to be a helpful resource for potential customers:

Mikey’s Pizza: A Crested Butte Favorite

For those seeking a satisfying and convenient meal in Crested Butte, Colorado, Mikey’s Pizza stands out as a consistently well-regarded establishment. Located at 611 3rd St, Crested Butte, CO 81224, and reachable at Phone: 9703491110, Mikey’s offers a complete dining experience catering to a wide range of preferences. Their website, Website: mikeyspizza.net, provides a wealth of information, including menus and operating hours.

Specialties and Services

Mikey’s Pizza is primarily a pizza restaurant, but its offerings extend beyond traditional pies. They also operate a convenient delivery service, alongside a fully-fledged restaurant and a popular sandwich shop. Customers can enjoy their meals in several ways: dine-in, takeout, or via delivery. The restaurant itself is designed to be welcoming, offering outdoor seating – a particularly appealing feature during Crested Butte’s pleasant weather.

Key Features and Accessibility

Mikey’s has clearly prioritized accessibility and convenience. They provide wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. Furthermore, they accept a variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. Free street parking is available nearby, simplifying the parking process. They are also dog-friendly, allowing canine companions to join their customers outside.

Dining Experience & Menu Highlights

The atmosphere at Mikey’s is generally described as casual and family-friendly, making it a comfortable choice for a relaxed meal. They cater to a diverse clientele, including college students, tourists, and anyone seeking a delicious comfort food or a quick bite. The menu features a range of options, including vegetarian options and a selection of desserts. The quality of the ingredients is consistently praised – notably the freshness of their salads and the robust flavor of their signature red sauce.

Customer Feedback & Reputation

Mikey’s Pizza boasts a strong reputation, as evidenced by the 176 reviews on Google My Business, with an average opinion of 4.5/5. The consistently positive feedback highlights their commitment to quality and service. Many customers specifically mention the generous size of their calzones, suggesting a generous portion size.

To learn more about their menu, hours, and special offers, we highly recommend visiting their website: mikeyspizza.net. We encourage you to contact them directly through their website to make a reservation or place an order for a truly enjoyable meal in Crested Butte

👍 Reviews of Mikey's Pizza

Baba F.

5/5

The calzones are very generously sized. The red sauce had a lot of flavor and complexity for a walkup joint. Easy order, easy delivery. The salad dressing was Ken's (not homemade) but did the job, and the greens were fresh.

Kyle H.

4/5

This location is a walk up and order pizza establishment. I was very happy to eat here twice in one day. The first order was perfect. The dough was NY style very large,tasty, and crispy. I wanted more so after my event in town, I ordered a to-go (large garden salad, pepperoni roll, spinach roll, cheesesteak sandwich, extreme cheesesteak sandwich). I did not receive my entree a large dinner salad. Thankfully my family shared their sandwiches which both were delicious. The pepperoni roll was very doughy. Though the spinach roll was delicious.

Marlene V.

5/5

We absolutely loved Mikey’s Pizza; we ended going twice. The best pizza in Crested Butte. The first night there, my husband forgot his drink so we drove all the way back 3 min before closing and they were kind enough to open the door right before they locked up. The ingredients are perfect and the sauce is amazing. Definitely a thumbs up, check it out if you’re ever in Crested Butte.

skylar W.

5/5

best $4 you can ever spend on a huge thin crust slice! despite the rest of this town having seemingly steep food prices, these guys are cooking up some amazing pizza for a low price. super friendly hole in the wall! definitely recommend!

Mandy V.

1/5

WARNING This restaurant is the worst place to get food I have ever been to. The food looks and tastes like dog food. I wouldn't even feed it to my dog.

Stephen O.

5/5

The most NY of crusts around. They are willing to customize their pizzas. Brought the team pickles, vinegar chips, and cream cheese and they put together a masterpiece of a pizza!

Ron L.

4/5

Fantastic hidden gem in Crested Butte. Just off the main drag tucked into a small building across from the Skate park. The breakfast burrito is incredible and sized for 2 meals. Pizza by slice during lunch is a hard to beat on price and quality. Skip the lines and head to Miley’s for a great culinary experience.

Cam T.

5/5

Got a delicious hot slice of cheese pizza that was bomb and then a cheesesteak extreme and a white cc macadamia cookie. Everything was fresh and fire.