Mama Lisa Restaurant - Mastic, New York

Mama Lisa Restaurant

Mama Lisa Restaurant, located at 1226 Montauk Hwy in Mastic, NY, stands as a beloved culinary destination in the region. This family-style Italian restaurant has garnered significant attention for its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for both locals and tourists seeking quality dining experiences. With a reputation built over time, the establishment offers a comprehensive menu catering to diverse tastes, complemented by a range of services designed for convenience and comfort.

Location and Ambiance

Situated along the scenic Montauk Highway in the charming village of Mastic, Mama Lisa benefits from its proximity to the North Fork's attractions, including beaches and vineyards. The restaurant's location is easily accessible, and its premises are thoughtfully designed to accommodate various guest preferences. Patrons often comment on the cozy yet lively ambiance, which successfully blends a casual, relaxed feel with touches of sophistication, creating an environment suitable for a wide array of occasions, from intimate dinners to family celebrations.

Key Characteristics

Several factors contribute to Mama Lisa's enduring popularity. Its commitment to quality ingredients is evident in its dishes, particularly in its Italian and seafood specialties. The restaurant prides itself on offering classic comfort food executed with modern flair, ensuring that each plate is both familiar and exciting. Furthermore, Mama Lisa distinguishes itself through its attentive service and efficient operations, which consistently meet or exceed customer expectations.

Specialties and Cuisine

At the heart of Mama Lisa's menu lies its authentic Italian cuisine, prepared with a focus on tradition and innovation. Signature dishes often highlight rich sauces, fresh pasta, and perfectly grilled or pan-seared seafood, catering to those seeking an unforgettable taste of the Mediterranean. The restaurant's expertise in seafood preparation, as noted in numerous reviews, is a particular highlight for many diners. Beyond Italian staples, Mama Lisa also offers a selection of American fare and other international options, ensuring a versatile dining experience. The extensive drink menu includes a carefully curated wine list, an impressive array of craft beers, creative cocktails, and expertly brewed coffee, rounding out the overall culinary journey.

Services and Accessibility

Mama Lisa is committed to providing exceptional service tailored to the needs of its diverse clientele. The restaurant offers a comprehensive range of services, including dine-in, takeaway, and delivery options. Outdoor seating areas allow guests to enjoy their meals in the pleasant Long Island weather, while indoor tables provide a more sheltered experience. For those preferring convenience without leaving their vehicles, kerbside pickup is available. In response to current health concerns and evolving customer preferences, the restaurant also facilitates no-contact delivery, ensuring safety and ease for patrons. The venue is fully wheelchair accessible, with features such as an accessible parking area, entrance, seating, and toilet, demonstrating a commitment to inclusivity for all guests.

Customer Experience

The overwhelmingly positive reviews on Google My Business, averaging 4.4/5 from over 1700 assessments, speak volumes about the quality of Mama Lisa's offerings and service. Customers consistently praise the delicious food, with particular acclaim for the seafood dishes, appetizers like stuffed mushrooms, and other signature items. The friendly and professional service received by many patrons is another recurring theme in the feedback. Reviews also frequently mention the cozy ambiance, efficient service that keeps large parties flowing smoothly, and the welcoming atmosphere suitable for celebrations of all sizes. The restaurant's reputation for providing a great dining experience includes commendable options for various dietary preferences, such as vegetarian and healthy choices.

Practical Information

For reservations, especially for larger groups or weekend evenings, it is recommended to book in advance via telephone or the website. The phone number, 631-395-4600, connects directly with the restaurant to assist with inquiries or bookings. Alternatively, the dedicated website at mamalisarestaurant.com provides detailed information about the menu, hours of operation, and reservation options. Free street parking is available, and there is also a free parking lot on-site to accommodate guests. The establishment accepts various payment methods, including credit and debit cards, as well as NFC mobile payments, offering convenience for all customers.

Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner, a family-friendly meal, or catering services, Mama Lisa Restaurant presents itself as a versatile and reliable dining option in the Mastic area. Its combination of excellent food, attentive service, and accommodating facilities makes it a noteworthy establishment for anyone exploring the culinary scene of the North Fork.

👍 Reviews of Mama Lisa Restaurant

Anthony (.

5/5

I grew up with the very best Italian food in NYC. I am a very picky mofo. I was totally impressed with the seafood platter with marinara sauce, the stuffed mushrooms and the clams. Home run dinner. 👏 Bravo!

Stephanie M.

5/5

Had a wonderful dinner at Mama Lisa in Mastic a few weeks back, celebrating a birthday. Party of 11. Service was friendly and polite, and food was delicious. Restaurant was hopping, but appetizers were served quickly and entrees were perfectly timed. Seafood was exceptional. Definitely worth a visit!

P W.

5/5

Trained by an Italian chef, their food rivals my own!

The Veal Marsala is made with fresh ingredients and is cooked to perfection.

The stuffed eggplant appetizer was awesome!

Outstanding friendly service, and very comfortable dining room.

Highly recommended.

Linda F.

5/5

If you're looking for "your spot" this is it. The penne ala vodka is amazing, Traditional spaghetti and meatballs are so good. The service is fabulous and after your second time, you feel like you just walked into a friend's house that was expecting you. Sit at the bar, at a booth or table, doesn't matter. I cater most my parties from there.

Darren N.

4/5

The food was really good and everyone was really friendly.

We had reservations and were seated on time.

Most dishes are about $20 and it's a pretty long menu.

It was the first restaurant that I went to that boxes your left over food for you. The

With portion of food that get, I think things are fairly priced and it's actually a nice little spot. If you enjoy Italian food then it's a nice place to go for a date night. They also do have a bar.

Free parking onsite and a parking lot across the street. I am not sure if parking across the street was free. It seems to get bus around 7pm so plan accordingly

Daniel M.

5/5

Very nice place. Loved the layout! The food was excellent! They also make pizza there. When I was there there were a lot of people at the bar having a good time.

Steph G.

5/5

Everything was delicious!
Quite bit of a wait time but staff was always updating on estimated time. We received complimentary desert, will be going back with my family! Definitely recommend

Sal V.

4/5

Update: everything on the menu really is very good. I’m never disappointed when I eat here. Food is made with love and it shows. That you Momma Lisas for being consistent and making great food.!!!!!The food is good and worth the price . The staff is always super friendly. Their eggplant is the best around .