Jay's Deli - Highland Mills, New York

Jay's Deli: A Delightful Dining Experience

Located at 534 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY 10930, Jay's Deli is a renowned deli and breakfast restaurant that has been delighting customers with its delicious offerings and exceptional service. With a phone number of 59282803 and a website at jaysdeli.net, Jay's Deli is easily accessible and conveniently located for those seeking a satisfying meal.

Specialties and Services

Specializing in deli fare, breakfast dishes, and a wide variety of other culinary delights, Jay's Deli is a one-stop-shop for all your food cravings. Other points of interest include delivery, in-store pickup, onsite services, takeout, same-day delivery, wheelchair accessibility, and a quick visit option. The deli accepts multiple forms of payment, including credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments, SNAP/EBT, and offers free parking lot and street parking.

Testimonials and Reviews

With 634 reviews on Google My Business and an average rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars, Jay's Deli has proven itself to be a top choice for breakfast and deli lovers alike. Customers rave about the deli's great sandwiches, hot food, and extensive selection of drinks and snacks. The staff is consistently praised for their friendliness and the cleanliness of the establishment is always noted.

One satisfied customer stated, 'Love it, my friend recommended Jays and I am so happy. Great sandwich and hot food.' Another reviewer noted, 'Definitely recommend their regular macaroni salad. Best I’ve ever had.' A third reviewer appreciated the 'Great food and good prices. Customer service is always excellent.'

In conclusion, Jay's Deli is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a delicious and satisfying dining experience. With its diverse menu, exceptional service, and impressive reviews, it's no wonder that Jay's Deli has become a beloved institution in Highland Mills, NY.

👍 Reviews of Jay's Deli

Ines R.

5/5

Love it, my friend recommended Jays and I am so happy. Great sandwich and hot food. Great selection of drinks and snacks. Staff always friendly and place is always clean. We get dinner/lunch for whole family.

Joseph G.

5/5

Very nice people just went there on 6-8-24. Definitely recommend their regular macaroni salad. Best I’ve ever had. And I don’t like macaroni salad but they have very good stuff all around.

carlos G.

5/5

Great food and good prices. Customer service is always excellent. Currently under renovation as of 3.18.2025

Heyits A.

5/5

I have zero complaints, staff is nice, food is great, and the building is clean unlike the other delis in the area. If I ever experienced a mistake, they are quick to fix it and never rude.

Yaz

5/5

I love it here it's my second home. From the owners to everything there is always a pleasure

Mix B. :.

4/5

Pretty good pizza for plain pizza my math teacher got it for us and it was pretty good.

D'Lauren R.

4/5

It was fairly good, though it took a bit to get food in the line

jacqueline M.

5/5

It's a lovely little deli. The perfect go to spot for the residents, who uses Jay for everything. The food is really good there and plus they cater for occasions. From pastries to pizza or just some grocery items that you run out of at home.