Ice Cream Cottage - Mastic, New York

Ice Cream Cottage: A Delightful Frozen Treat Destination

Address: 1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950, United States

Phone: 6313953580

Website: icecreamcottage.net

Specialties: Ice cream shop

Other points of interest: Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, On-site services, Takeaway, Same-day delivery, Solo dining, Wheelchair-accessible car park, Coffee, Casual, Trending, Quick visit, Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Credit cards, Good for kids.

Opinions: This company has 875 reviews on Google My Business.

Average opinion: 4.6/5.

Ice Cream Cottage, located at 1590 Montauk Hwy in Mastic, NY, is a charming destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. This delightful ice cream shop offers a wide variety of flavors, catering to all preferences and palates. From classic vanilla and chocolate to unique and inventive flavors, Ice Cream Cottage has something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Ice Cream Cottage is the quality of their ice cream. The shop prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, ensuring that each scoop is creamy, smooth, and bursting with flavor. The flavors are not only delicious but incredibly accurate, with each one crafted to taste just like the flavor it represents. For example, the cappuccino chip flavor actually contains real cinnamon, adding a homemade touch that cannot be replicated.

Despite its many strengths, Ice Cream Cottage does have one minor drawback: the temperature of their ice cream. Some customers have noted that the ice cream is not kept cold enough, making it a bit too soft for their liking. However, this is a minor issue that does not detract from the overall enjoyment of the ice cream.

With its wide variety of flavors, high-quality ingredients, and friendly atmosphere, Ice Cream Cottage is definitely worth a visit for anyone seeking a delightful frozen treat. The shop's convenient location, combined with its excellent customer reviews and average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, makes it a top choice for ice cream enthusiasts in the area.

Keywords: Ice Cream Cottage, ice cream shop, Mastic, NY, flavors, quality ingredients, customer reviews

👍 Reviews of Ice Cream Cottage

Veronica

4/5

This place was very nice. I tried many flavors and they were all delicious. The flavors were not only good but incredibly accurate. The cappuccino chip flavor had actual cinnamon in it, and each flavor was the same, crafted to taste just like the flavor it was and with a homemade touch that cannot be faked. I give it four stars because the ice cream wasn't kept cold enough for my liking. It was too soft, in my opinion, but it tasted delicious so that made up for it. Taste-wise, this place would be hard to beat, so it is definitely worth a try.

Amy K.

4/5

One of the best ice cream place in Long Island. We used to come here with three kids for many years. This time we came with one of our kids and she enjoyed 3 scoops of ice cream on waffle cone. Banana nut is so good!
Pistachio was not as good.
We had a fun time!

Quinn M.

2/5

Lived here for 22 years of my life, I love ice cream cottage, the service is not the same!!! This is the second time in a row we were rushed out of the door. I’m a manager of a restaurant I completely understand wanting to go home and closing up but we came 30 min before closing and wasn’t taking long to order, we didn’t get any toppings we wanted the girl just closed our ice creams and it felt super rushed!!! This is the second time the same girl did this in a row, I can’t resist not going here ever again but I think it’s gonna be a supper long time before I go back again.

P G.

1/5

Usually go to Ralph’s but they close for the winter, so tried the cottage I hear so much about. Honestly it sucked, ordered a Sunday soft ice cream with peanut butter sauce and chocolate crunch. So for $9.95 I got a cup of ice cream with literally 1squirt of peanut butter on top and a teaspoon of chocolate crunch. RIPOFF!!! Was really disappointing. Ralph’s put toppings bottom, middle and top, all I got here was a cup of ice cream with PRACTICALLY NOTHING ON IT! I don’t know do the employees have to pay for toppings they put on people’s Sundays I’m done with this place, DEFINITELY DO NOT RECOMMEND

CM

4/5

Tons of flavor choices and unique ones & toppings.Sell Ice cream cakes & candy. The waffle bowls are great! However don't assume you will like their version of a flavor you are used to. I suggest ask to TASTE BEFORE YOU BUY. I tried couple and no thanks. My fan is pistachio, they have 2 choices for Sicilian-to me tastes pasty or pistachio nut idky but didn't like either so wasn't having it.

Christian T.

5/5

Great service! Was surprised how easy it was to order a custom cake online. And it came out great. They placed the image I requested, and the letters used for the inscription looked perfect. Just had to get the decorations from Amazon. Will definitely come back in the summer. Thanks!

Massbaum

4/5

We just brought our kids here and they loved it.. Having grown up just east of Mastic, I only went to the Ice Cream Cottage once when I was about 10 years old, but I’ve been aware of this place as a local landmark for most of my life.. We recently heard that their ice cream was “homemade” so we thought we’d give it a try.. Their selection of flavors was pretty impressive, and they offer ice cream, gelato, sorbet and even Italian ices (they even had a vegan soft serve option).. We all found something that sounded appealing and tasted delicious!! They have a wide selection of toppings as well as cones, from sugar or waffle to pretzel or Oreo.. It was very crowded when we visited but it was all part of the fun and the line moved quickly.. Honestly we had just chosen our orders by the time we reached the counter. The prices were definitely reasonable if not cheap.. After we got our orders we joined all of the other customers outside on benches and ate our ice cream while our kids played with some new friends.. We didn’t try the cakes, so I can’t offer any feedback there, but the ice cream was great.. I’d say it was better quality and more appealing selection than Haagen Dazs or Ben & Jerry’s at a lower cost.. Side note, they have a HUGE selection of candy, both new and old school, so you can definitely get your fix here!! All in all a fun family experience and a great option for an occasional treat..

CHRISTOPHER P.

2/5

Placed an order for pickup. Asked for spoons and napkins...none. almost 5$ for 2 scoops of ice cream. 4 scoop containers were smaller. Stopped going there because of accuracy issues. Flavors are still good. Just not what it used to be.