Frosty's Ice Cream - Depew, New York

鮭魚握壽司

The best ice cream I’ve ever had!!!! The price is affordable, spend five dollars n you’ll get two scoops of huuuuge ice cream!! (Though it’s too much for me, I can never just buy one scoop.) I can literally walk one hr every day just to have this, n even want to apply the job so I can have free ice cream everyday:)))
the ingredients inside are authentic, if you got orange pineapple, it rlly have so much pineapple in it. If you don’t like something too sweet, try kahlua almonds. That’s my favorite flavor!!!
I’ve been here couple months ago, n I already become a fan of it!!!!💗the workers here are rlly nice too, they always have smiles on their face n never get impatient when i need time to consider about the flavor.(since it has soooo many!!!)
Never wrote comments on google map before, but I need EVERYONE to try this before you leave buffalo:))))

Aa’liyah R.

Love this place when I’m in the area! They have dairy free and dairy options so great for both, also there’s a small train and tables in back for kids. I got a vegan ice cream cake from here in 2021 and it’s was good but hard to cut into so let it sit out to soften.
The service is good and they’re quick. Prices aren’t expensive and it’s worth it, the place is CASH ONLY!! If you don’t have cash then I’d suggest getting some before you come even tho there’s an atm, the MINIMUM cash withdraw for their atm $20 with a $2.5 fee and my bank charged $2.5 for foreign atms. Had to withdraw $20 with a $5 fee for my $5 ice cream which is tedious but ok I understand. I asked for a sample of one of the soft serve flavors to make sure I chose correct and they don’t do samples which is crazy to me, I was spending money anyway and I’m a returning customer so I thought maybe a small amount on a spoon would be ok. I don’t care much about it being cash only but the no sample thing is a bit weird imo. How else am I supposed to figure if I will like the flavor I’m about to buy?
Also when I asked the girl for a cup for my tall ice cream cone so I could put it in and drive away, she gave me such a small dish when I clearly have a huge amount of ice cream so I had to ask for a blue Pepsi cup and she didn’t want to give it to me by the look in her face but I explained I wanted to use the cup bc I had to drive and I can’t hold the ice cream cone at the same time.
Otherwise I do really like this place, their ice cream flavors are unique and taste great. The small train for kids is fun for all kids of all ages.

Racheal D.

The cashiers were super friendly and fast. The kitchen looked clean as well as clean tables to sit at and enjoy your iceceam. The soft serve was creamy and delicious. I had a tropical frosty, and it was tangy and sweet 😋

Peggy P.

I've been to both locations. Love the vegan options! Always incredible service. My husband got this amazing cannoli sundae. Almost too pretty to eat.

Jessica K.

Just picked up a birthday ice cream cake for my husband and it's perfect! The staff there was super nice and even let me come back with my gift certificate that I forgot and refunded me the money. Will be using them again for custom ice cream cakes!

Shaliza S.

Little ice cream shack on a busy road. They have seating behind the building. It was a long line when we went but they worked it pretty quickly. We had three cones and enjoyed a quieter evening.

The first time we had visited there the parking lot was packed and the line was wrapped around so we had left.

Kristen R.

Frosty’s has never let us down with one of their amazing and tasty cakes but this one really “takes the cake”. The owner really really outdid himself for my daughters second birthday cake. Wow. Just wow.

Danielle L.

The best sorbet I've had in New York! It had a rich, real flavor and was the consistency of Gelato. I can't say enough about how fantastic it was. I should have asked if they sold it in take-home containers. I'll definitely be back.