Dominick's Italian-American Deli - New Hyde Park, New York

Margie A.

I was greeted by the owners daughter Danielle; very sweet and the atmosphere was loving and family oriented.
Got my food in a timely manner considering it was crowded with patrons waiting patiently.
I got the Antonio hero a loaded delicious meal even though it’s a sandwich.
I got a pound of their famous signature chicken fingers, which are well known at this establishment.
As I waited on line everyone was talking about how delicious the chicken fingers are.
Shout out to Dom’s Italian Deli, Danielle and all the great employees behind the scene.
I will definitely be a customer from here on in.

mikecastella

For a deli the product that they deliver is delicious. I’ve been coming here since my family moved out here over 25 years ago last year I stopped going to this place because the pricing is just gotten ridiculous I get it prices go up, but this place is taking it to another level a pound of turkey being $17.99 is bonkers than during charging percentages for me to use a credit card or a debit card now a sandwich is probably pushing close to $13 or possibly more depending on what you get and when you got a sandwich, they used to give you a little Dixie cup of potato salad, macaroni, salad, or coleslaw, which was cool then it became just a specialty sandwiches then they just got rid of it completely ever since the pandemic the prices have gone up dramatically in the past five years the customer service could be better. The food is great. Things have just gotten so stingy with this place that I will not come back. I’d rather take my business somewhere else maybe I’ll come back one day if prices again become reasonable.

M O.

Great place, delicious food, service magnificent, the crew behind the counter super friendly!! Spacious parking in the back. Chicken sandwiches cutlet delicious. I ate a chicken, cutlet, fresh mozzarella, little bit mayo, and lettuce.

Coffee pretty good.

Cynthia

We didn’t really like the santiago, the bread was soggy when we got home and the vodka parm didn’t have enough sauce. chicken fingers were pretty good

Ryan T.

The chicken fingers are so elite, they’re like torn up chicken cutlets so you get a variety of shapes and sizes. Add the honey mustard and it’s a combination so addicting you’ll be stuffing them into your mouth at a rapid pace

Max C.

Best deli in the area, with a awesome variety of sandwiches. Would recommend the Broadway, the Lorenzo and of course the chicken tenders. Parking is very convenient and staff works quickly.

Bincy J.

I asked my friend for a recommendation for a place where I can order some food for a party. She recommended getting some sandwiches and maybe chicken fingers from Dominick's. It was an excellent recommendation. The sandwich portions were generous and the chicken fingers were delicious and I thought it was a very decent value. The deli itself is an authentic Italian style deli with some unique offerings and lots of prepared foods and a deli counter. I hope smaller institutions like these can get tons of support from the community to stay alive and keep bringing authentic food to the people. I saw a few people purchase fried Chicken cutlets to go and if I come back soon, I will definitely add that to my list!

George E.

Visited on the recommendation of a social media influencer. I will be second guessing all his recommendations moving forward.

The establishment has a tiny parking lot suitable for approximately 5-6 cars.

Upon arrival the layout of the establishment is a bit confusing but I was able to order a sandwich since it appears they have two areas to order. One area is for sandwiches and the other appears to be for breakfast items.

I ordered my sandwich; breaded chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella and prosciutto. I received the sandwich relatively cold and on bread that didn’t enhance the experience of the sandwich. I personally wasn’t a fan of the bread or the cold breaded chicken cutlet. I was expecting a warm to hot sandwich.

I will attempt to return since they seem to make their own chicken tenders/fingers.