Calissa Hamptons - Water Mill, New York

s A.

Calissa offers a delightful dining experience with its cozy ambiance and friendly, attentive service.. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual and refined, making it ideal for a relaxed yet elevated meal.
Both the salmon and grilled pork chop stood out--cooked to perfection at the right temperature. The salmon came exact medium rare with crispy skin, and the grilled pork chop was juicy. Both dishes were simple in their preparation but packed with flavor, showcasing the restaurant's skill in letting quality ingredients shine.
Overall, a lovely spot that delivers on both taste and service, making it a must-try for those craving a cozy and flavorful Greek dining experience.

Darlene R.

The atmosphere and the drinks were the best part of the night. We went during off season. Therefore, we escaped the crowd. The food was flavorful. I still prefer the city for multicultural food, but this is what they had. I would go back if I'm in the Hamptons.

Lorenzo

Calissa Hamptons is a true find. From the moment we walked in, we felt welcomed by the friendly staff, and the atmosphere struck the perfect balance between casual and elegant—just right for a night out.

The food at Calissa really shines. The Lobster Pasta was a standout, rich, flavorful and satisfying, while the Tuna Crudo was incredibly fresh and delicate. The Salmon was perfectly cooked and full of flavor, and the Zucchini Chips? Crispy, light, and impossible to stop eating. Pair those with their dip spreads and warm pita, and you’ve got a winning combination.

It’s rare to find a place where every dish hits the mark, but Calissa managed to do just that. Whether you're a regular or it's your first visit, you’re in for something special here.

Barsnobs

What can I say? One of a kind. This place is top notch. The staff, amazing! The food, best Mediterranean dishes I've had! The drinks were fresh and tasty. I recommend the swordfish and salmon. Leek rice was so good. Mexican drink was good! Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya.

Kelly M. M.

The ambiance was great and so was the service. We were disappointed that both steaks came out more cooked than we would have preferred, we ordered MR. For $48 each, were thought they were pretty bland and forgettable. Not to the point of complaining because we were hungry but it could have been better.

By contrast, the apps were fantastic, specifically the octopus and the yellowfin crudo, I thought both were amazing and I don't typically like seafood. The avocado tzatziki was also memorable.

I love an espresso martini but I thought this version was a little too bitter or coffee forward, it needed better balance.

Shere S.

Went to this venue/restaurant for a Gorgon City concert. Great atmosphere very intimate small crowd, the venue was in tents outside, but it was not grungy in any way and the atmosphere was very tropical. Crowd was great. Drinks were incredible, they serve pitchers of certain drinks, including margaritas, which is what we got, and it was very good. Didn’t get the food so I can’t read it but we did snack on some french fries and they were great lol

Ivan K.

Calissa is a Greek style restaurant located in the heart of the Hamptons. Featuring an array of seafood dishes, Calissa’s menu focuses on seafood and Greek dishes such as baked fish, steak, seafood pasta and cold mezze. From the appetizers to the main course, all dishes were well prepared and had excellent flavor/texture. I will note that I personally enjoyed the mezze and appetizers more than the main courses. The wine selection was extraordinary featuring a wide range of options for every palate.

Overall the atmosphere was great and the service was as expected. If you are in the area, Calissa is worth checking out.

BookLi S.

Calissa is an amazing restaurant - the food is exceptional and the ambience is gorgeous. We love eating at Calissa in the fall and winter when the dishes are rustic and hearty. In the spring and summer there is often great entertainment too!
I love being able to eat out and savor the food while staying on my Mediterranean diet. I try to eat gluten-free and Calissa is very accommodating with special diets.

There aren't a lot of super restaurants in Hamptons, so I keep going back to Calissa where I am always surprised and delighted by the experience.