Beartown Peaches N Cream - Painted Post, New York

Address: 5 Beartown Rd, Painted Post, NY 14870.
Phone: 79375219.
Website: facebook.com
Specialties: Ice cream shop.
Other points of interest: Onsite services, Takeout, Delivery, Same-day delivery, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Coffee, Casual, Groups, Quick visit, Credit cards, Good for kids.
Opinions: This company has 711 reviews on Google My Business.
Average opinion: 4.7/5.

📌 Location of Beartown Peaches N Cream

Beartown Peaches N Cream 5 Beartown Rd, Painted Post, NY 14870

☎️79375219

⏰ Open Hours of Beartown Peaches N Cream

Monday: 10 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 10 AM–9 PM
Friday: 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 10 AM–9 PM
Sunday: 10 AM–9 PM

Beartown Peaches N Cream

Beartown Peaches N Cream is a delightful ice cream shop located at 5 Beartown Rd, Painted Post, NY 14870. This popular destination offers a wide range of delicious ice cream flavors and is well-known for its friendly atmosphere and exceptional customer service.

The shop specializes in serving high-quality ice cream, with a focus on unique and creative flavors that cater to all tastes. Some of their most popular offerings include their signature Peaches N Cream flavor, as well as other seasonal and rotating selections that keep customers coming back for more.

Beartown Peaches N Cream is committed to providing a comfortable and enjoyable experience for all visitors. The shop offers various onsite services, including takeout and delivery options, ensuring that customers can easily enjoy their favorite treats at home or on the go. Same-day delivery is also available for added convenience.

The shop is wheelchair accessible, with both a wheelchair-friendly entrance and parking lot, making it easy for everyone to visit. In addition to their delicious ice cream, Beartown Peaches N Cream also offers a range of beverages, including coffee, ensuring that customers can satisfy their sweet tooth alongside their caffeine fix.

With a 4.7/5 average rating based on 711 reviews on Google My Business, Beartown Peaches N Cream has established itself as a beloved local favorite. Customers praise the shop for its friendly staff, wide selection of flavors, and overall welcoming atmosphere.

Whether you're looking for a quick treat or a place to enjoy a casual meal with friends and family, Beartown Peaches N Cream is the perfect destination. The shop's inviting ambiance and commitment to quality make it a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable ice cream experience.

Specialties: Ice cream shop

Other points of interest: Onsite services, Takeout, Delivery, Same-day delivery, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Coffee, Casual, Groups, Quick visit, Credit cards, Good for kids

Phone: 79375219

Website: facebook.com

👍 Reviews of Beartown Peaches N Cream

Beartown Peaches N Cream - Painted Post, New York

R K.

4/5

Evening Treat at Beartown Peaches & Cream – A Soft Serve Sampler in Painted Post, NY

Stopped by Beartown Peaches & Cream in Painted Post, NY, for a quick ice cream fix. The place has that nostalgic roadside charm, with a big, bold sign and a casual walk-up window that makes it feel like summer even on cooler evenings. I decided to try their soft serve chocolate and espresso coffee swirl, served in a cup with a fun upside-down cone stuck on top—definitely a playful presentation that made for a great photo-op.

As for the flavor, it was okay but didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The chocolate was smooth but very mild, and the espresso flavor was quite faint—almost unnoticeable. I was hoping for a stronger coffee punch, especially since espresso usually has a bold profile. The texture of the soft serve was creamy and pleasant, but the overall taste didn’t wow me.

That said, I have a feeling their hard ice cream options might be stronger in flavor and worth coming back for. This visit felt more like a casual stop than a standout ice cream experience, but the setting is friendly and inviting.

If you’re passing through and want something sweet, it’s still worth checking out—just maybe skip the soft serve and try the scoops instead!

The B. W. (.

5/5

This is an absolutely wonderful store. All local foods and produce. Their greenhouse full of mums is so fun to visit. They not only serve ice cream but also have a unique variety of products to choose from. I highly recommend you visit if you're in the area.

Meg S.

5/5

Lines can get pretty long, but it's worth the wait. Read their sizing chart before ordering anything bigger than a small. Great food.

Laurie A.

5/5

Best ice cream around. The prices are so reasonable and the cones are huge! I got the child size and it was just right. Usually I would go for a medium! They have tons of flavors to choose from. I forgot to take a picture, when I go back, which I definitely will I will update!

Juliana S.

5/5

This place is so great! I don't have any pictures to post because we're always having too much fun to think of it. The prices can't be beat (3 adults ordered for 12.50), the quality and selection is incomparable, and the staff is always the nicest and sweetest.

Update: ownership has changed but it remains the same awesome place to go. Prices and selection just can't be beat! And the staff are the best! Not pictured are the flavors of the day. Everyday has a new dole whip flavor and other specials.

Ann M. B.

5/5

Definitely a cool place to take the family. Outstanding service, absolutely delicious ice cream menu. And plenty of goods to shop for in the the farmers market. All very reasonably priced. You will not be disappointed.

Pam B.

5/5

The servings are huge! Staff is friendly, and your order is done quickly. Prices are high, but so is everything else in the world. It's always busy, so be patient.

Jenn B.

5/5

Their ice cream is delicious and there's quite a variety to choose from. They have both hard and soft ice cream, slushies, italian ice, ice pops, sundaes, milkshakes, coffee and more. Their prices are extremely reasonable too and their portion sizes are extremely generous.

Note: if you're dairy free, you have to try the DF Peanut Butter & Cookie ice cream - it's to die for!