Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes) - Melville, New York

Bake Me a Cake by Angela: A Gourmet Cake Experience

Bake Me a Cake by Angela is a highly regarded cake shop located at 12 Grossman St, Melville, NY 11747, known for its exquisite custom cakes made to order. This women-owned business boasts a 4.8/5 average rating from 57 Google reviews, testifying to the high quality and satisfaction of its customers.

Specialties include a wide array of delicious cakes for any occasion, from weddings to birthdays. The shop is LGBTQ+ friendly and offers curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and same-day delivery, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their delectable creations.

One of the standout features of Bake Me a Cake by Angela is the exceptional taste and texture of its cakes. Customers rave about the flavor combinations and the difficulty in choosing just one. Many guests at weddings and events have inquired about the source of these incredible cakes, a testament to the skill and dedication of the bakery.

The owner, Angela, is known for her helpful and easy-to-work-with demeanor, making the cake ordering process a breeze. Customers appreciate the personal touch and attention to detail that Angela provides, ensuring that each cake is perfect for the occasion.

In addition to its delectable cakes, the shop also offers the option for customers to schedule an appointment for a tasting, allowing them to experience the quality of the cakes firsthand. The bakery accepts various payment methods, including checks, credit cards, and debit cards.

Bake Me a Cake by Angela is also wheelchair accessible, making it an inclusive space for all customers. The dedication to quality, customer service, and creating unique and beautiful cakes has made Bake Me a Cake by Angela a must-try for cake enthusiasts in the Melville area.

Don't miss out on the chance to indulge in a gourmet cake experience. Visit Bake Me a Cake by Angela at 12 Grossman St, Melville, NY 11747 or contact them by phone at 18040057 or via their website at bakemeacakebyangela.com.

👍 Reviews of Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes)

KT T.

5/5

We got our wedding cake from Angela and it was AMAZING!! I would highly recommend getting a cake from her for any occasion. We ordered some tasting cupcakes to determine which flavor combo to go with and it was so hard to choose - the flavor and texture of her cakes are outstanding! Lots of compliments and questions where we ordered it from from our guests. Also, Angela was so helpful and easy to work with.

luis N.

5/5

Angela’s far surpassed my expectations with the order I placed with her. She asked a few questions, made a couple of suggestions and together we came up with the perfect idea for my mother’s birthday cupcakes. Her attention to detail, creativity, presentation, and execution were perfect. I picked a few flavors, they were all excellent. My mother is a huge walking dead fan, she was blown away by the custom cupcakes. I will be ordering from Angela for all my future events. I recommend you do the same. Thank you Angela. Looking forward to tasting more of your delicious creations in the near future.

Anna W.

5/5

Best experience. I found Angela's website while searching online for a custom made cake. Angela was so easy to work with and made the most delicious 2 tiered cake and cupcakes for my daughters Bat mitzvah. She worked with my budget and turned my vision into delicious goodness. I'm still dreaming about them and it's been over a month! Shes officially my cake lady! I cant wait to use her again! Will not disappoint!!! Her frosting is spectacular!

Dana P.

5/5

I ordered a Barbie themed cake and gluten free cupcakes for my daughter's 5th bday and the flavors were incredible! The Barbie cake was strawberry cake with strawberry buttercream filling with vanilla frosting while the gluten-free cupcakes, which I refuse to share with anyone, were a chocolate cupcake with cannoli filling and almond frosting. My family are so happy there are leftovers. Highly recommend for any special occasion!

Ashley P.

5/5

Angela does fantastic cakes from my gender reveal to my daughters birthdays christening ect. Prices are so fair and her work is unbelievable!!!! Thank you thank you!!!

Carly L.

5/5

Angela made a bus themed cake for our daughter’s 2nd birthday. We asked for some special characters to be riding the bus and Angela graciously accommodated our requests! The cake was absolutely gorgeous and tasted wonderful too! Besides our daughter, it was the star of the party. We highly recommend Angela and will definitely be requesting her services again in the future!

Janette M.

5/5

Cannot be happier, cannot say enough about Angela! Her patience with me and my crazy ideas, how often I changed my mind. She made the PERFECT cake and it was delicious as well. I have had many pretty cakes that had no taste, not this one! She made individually wrapped cupcakes and boozy strawberries as favors that I am STILL getting compliments on! Hire this lady to make your special cake, you will NOT be disappointed! Thanks Angela!♡♡

Cathy M.

5/5

Angela makes the most Beautiful, most Delicious cakes and desserts Ever! I've been a repeat customer for years and will continue to look to her for any and every special occasion!