Anthony's Pizza - Mastic Beach, New York

Anthony's Pizza: A Delightful Dining Experience

Located at 520 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951, Anthony's Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant that offers a wide range of delicious dishes. With a phone number of 17725401, customers can easily reach out to place their orders or ask any questions. The restaurant's website, anthonyspizza0.godaddysites.com, provides detailed information about their menu, services, and location.

Specialties and Services

Specialties: Pizza restaurant.

Other points of interest: Curbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Drive-through, Takeout, Dine-in, Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible seating, Comfort food, Quick bite, Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Dessert, Seating, Restroom, Casual, Cozy, Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Credit cards, Good for kids, High chairs, Free parking lot, Free street parking, Parking, Dogs allowed outside.

Customer Opinions

Opinions: This company has 111 reviews on Google My Business.

Anthony's Pizza has received an impressive average opinion rating of 4.4/5, reflecting the high satisfaction of its customers. Many patrons praise the restaurant for its delicious and reasonably priced food, as well as its comfortable and cozy ambiance. The variety of services offered, such as curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and drive-through options, cater to different preferences and needs, making it a convenient choice for busy individuals and families.

A frequent comment among satisfied customers is the quality of the pizza, with mentions of the perfectly cooked crust and rich flavors. The chicken bacon ranch slice and meatball vodka parm hero on garlic bread are among the favorites, and the garlic knots are a notable side dish, as they are not dry and full of garlic. The restaurant's ability to cater to various dietary needs and preferences is also appreciated, as seen in the diverse menu options available.

In addition to its food, Anthony's Pizza is known for its welcoming atmosphere, making it an excellent choice for solo diners, families, and individuals seeking a comfortable and relaxed dining experience. The restaurant's commitment to accessibility is evident in its wheelchair-friendly entrance, parking lot, and seating areas, ensuring that all customers can enjoy their meals without any barriers.

The combination of exceptional food, convenient services, and a welcoming ambiance has earned Anthony's Pizza a loyal customer base and a strong reputation in the community. With its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, it is no wonder that this pizza restaurant continues to be a popular choice for locals and visitors alike.

👍 Reviews of Anthony's Pizza

Sean B.

5/5

I visited Anthony’s Pizza for the first time on November 30th on a spur-of-the-moment decision, and I’m so glad I did! The chicken bacon ranch slice was absolutely delicious—perfectly cooked and packed with flavor. The prices were very reasonable, and the overall experience was great. I’ll definitely be coming back to try more! Highly recommend!

Calvin S.

5/5

Ordered a meatball vodka parm hero on garlic bread. It was fantastic. Also ordered a regular slice and garlic knots. Pizza had a nice thin crust. The garlic knots were surprisingly not dry and full of garlic. I believe I found my new pizza spot.

Ashley M.

1/5

Horrible service and attitude!!! I ordered 4 slices of pizza (Chicken parm, vodka, a Sicilian slice, and 2 plain slices of pizza). I placed the order in slice around 1:30 and received a call one of the kinds I chose are not available. I chose something else and 45 minutes go by. I called the restaurant (mind you the pizza place is up the same road from my job, my jobs on Pineway Ave) to inquire when the food is coming
Because it’s literally up the street and 4 slices they had to heat up, not make from scratch. The guy on the phone then tells me they just left with the box of food and they gave something extra (as if to accommodate me for taking so long, over an hour at this point for 4 slices). When we finally received the food the chicken parm is dry, all of the pizza was cold and my friend had to literally chizzle her slices to detach them from the pizza box. Our pizza was cold (AGAIN they are right up the road). We called and the man on the phone has nerve to tell us he’s refunding it and with attitude told us not to call again. NO PROBLEM ANTHONYS pizza !!! Your pizza and service sucks anyway and you should consider retraining your staff because there are 15 other places in Mastic and your pizza isn’t anything to brag about 🙂 I suggest to all of my friends and fellow coworkers to never order here !!!!! The pictures show all of the remains of the pizza stuck to the box. We didn’t even want to eat it and it went straight to the trash because that’s what Anthony’s pizza is !!!!!!!!

Lola

1/5

Ordered food yesterday as they were the only place open first they charged a $2 community fee or whatever they are calling it which is ridiculous, second the food was horrible had us in the bathroom 20 minutes later violently assaulting the toilet , won’t be ordering anything from them again also thinking of calling the department of health obviously something wasn’t right with the food…. there’s no way to give zero stars but that’s what this place deserves

Mekhai G.

3/5

Decided to give Anthony’s Pizza a try… ordered a chicken Parm pie and a Caesar salad. Got there after estimated pickup time and salad wasn’t ready. Someone through salad together quickly and skimmed me. Pizza looked like chicken nugget pie rather than a chicken parmesan. Definitely did not get my money’s worth.Overall 3 star experience, 3 stars and that’s generous because i’m aware that it is a new business. Hope Anthony figures things out. Best of luck!

nick S.

1/5

Theres much better places for pizza than here. I got 2 regular slices and tbh it was so bad . Anyone who says this is the best pizza in mastic or that they have ever had , they only eat frozen pizza . Nothing about the pizza was good . The sauce ? If there was any sauce . The cheese tasted cheap. And the slices was so thin it didnt even fill me up. I will say the people are nice in there but my god the food is horrible. Also the other bad reviews kind of make sense to be fair😂. Would come back if they changed their recipe and give it another shot

lexi

5/5

anthony's pizza is a pizza place that is great , there workers are the kindest people and give great customer service and support. the happy and safe atmosphere there is incredible. and the food there is the best pizza i ever tasted. seeing the good community there at anthony's could really make you smile and so does the food. i really do hope the best for everyone there as a return to there kindness. make sure to eat at anthony's! 10/10🙏🙏

Butthead M.

1/5

I ordered a margarita for pickup from here off slice and it was the most vile disgusting pizza I've ever seen or tasted I couldn't even get one slice down. It looks as if they dumped a can of cheap old tomatoes all over the pizza without even bothering to drain them. The crust was soggy and mushy since it was covered in watery tomatoes juice. I've eaten pizza once a week almost every week for my entire life and never once has one been bad enough to complain about or not be able to eat. Ive tried just about all of the local pizza places and their margarita pies if they have them - ninos, johns/fratelis, pizza time, Los amigos, mama Lisa's - and while some are better than others every single pie I've gotten has been miles better than this pie from Anthony's. Tried to at least get my money back from Slice but Anthony's refused. I'll never go there again and I'll be sure to spread the word to stay away from there. By far the worst pizza in mastic.