Amore Pizza - East Northport, New York

Nick T.

Small hole in the wall pizza spot. Came in here quick for a slice before a dinner party bc I haven’t eaten anything all day. Service was fast and friendly and the vodka grandma slice was incredible! Deff give this place a shot if you’re in the area!! Will be back with the lady

Michael &. C. B.

I absolutely love their pizzas, as simple as a cheese pie, they make it so good, our favorite is also their chicken bbq. During the holidays I called in for large orders to be delivered at a certain time in the afternoon and they didn’t fail, were there on time, and all guest love the food! Fave pizza place in town!

Robert H.

My family lives in the area and suggested I go here to try their pizza. I had a regular Neapolitan slice and a buffalo chicken slice and was very happy. Not too doughy, not too saucy. Just right.

Walter W.

Im not usually a fan of Long Island pizza I prefer thinner crispier city style.

I was at local cigar lounge last night afross the street and a friend walked in with a few slices of pizza from this place. It looked really good so I walked over before closing.

I got two slices of Grandmas. Stiff crust, great undercarriage, not to thick, sauce had a very nice flavor, loved the couple of basil leaves on top enough to enhance flavor but not wash out. Not to much saice either just enough. Great crunch with each bite. I could hold the square without sag. Honestly this is one of my favorite slices if not my favorite I've had in Long Island.

Staff was super nice and quick. Very clean spot. Cant wait to get more.

Lynn M.

One tasteless Neapolitan slice, dripping with oil, for $3.70. So disappointing. Their quality has slipped as prices became high.
Chef's is still the best pizza in East Northport, hands down (and dough flying high😋)!!
This is the third 'stop by' for a slice on different days of the week in the last few month, just to be fair. Last visit. Sadly, was the go-to place in the neighborhood for 30+ years.

Brett M.

Pizzeria with great pizza and great food. Sesame crusted pizzas on the counter consisting of spinach, fresh tomato and pepperoni are all great choices. Many to choose from and they all move quickly. Nothing sits around and always fresh.The eggplant parmigiana and chicken parmigiana were fantastic also. Dinners come with side greek salads or pasta. Lots of specials. Owners are great and so is the staff.

Michael

Their grandma pie is great. We wanted to try their margherita pie thinking it would be of similar quality. Unfortunately, we really did not like it. It was not a traditional marg pie. It was a standard cheese pie with whole slices of tomatoes under the cheese, which made it very watery. It’s also winter, so the tomatoes were very low quality. It was also very bland, which is not what you would expect from a margherita pie.

Ryan W.

Kids running around throwing footballs in here… a lot of mad people standing around.

Two plain slices, 7.40. They were real boring, just bland. No taste of sauce on any bite. A horrible crust, frozen pizza crust.

Thin, greasy, and tasteless. Looked good, tasted meh. 2* for big slices