Hustler's Tavern - Lewiston, New York

Hustler's Tavern

Hustler's Tavern, located at 800 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092, is a popular destination for those seeking great food, drinks, and a lively atmosphere. With a phone number of 162462392 and website at hustlerstavern.com, this establishment has built a strong reputation in the local community.

The specialties at Hustler's Tavern include a delicious selection of pizzas, American cuisine, and a full bar with an impressive cocktail menu. Other notable features include outdoor seating, no-contact delivery options, delivery, takeout, dine-in service, and fast and friendly staff. The tavern also boasts a great beer selection, an extensive list of cocktails, and comfort food options that will satisfy any appetite. Vegetarian and small plate options are available, along with a variety of wines and desserts.

Hustler's Tavern is known for its cozy, trendy, and welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for solo diners, groups, and tourists alike. The establishment is wheelchair accessible and offers amenities such as wheelchair accessible parking and restrooms, as well as wheelchair accessible seating. With happy hour food specials and a casual, yet trendy vibe, this tavern is perfect for anyone looking to enjoy a delicious meal and a refreshing drink in a comfortable setting.

With a 4.5 out of 5-star rating based on 92 reviews on Google My Business, it's clear that Hustler's Tavern has earned a strong reputation for its exceptional service, quality food, and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat, a place to unwind after work, or a lively spot to gather with friends, Hustler's Tavern has something to offer.

Key features:

• Pizza restaurant
• American restaurant
• Bar
• Cocktail bar
• Outdoor seating
• No-contact delivery
• Delivery
• Takeout
• Dine-in
• Fast service
• Great beer selection
• Great cocktails
• Dinner
• Comfort food
• Happy hour food
• Small plates
• Vegetarian options
• Wine
• Dessert
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating
• Alcohol
• Beer
• Coffee
• Credit cards accepted
• Debit cards accepted
• NFC mobile payments accepted
• Casual atmosphere
• Cozy
• Trendy
• Groups welcome
• Perfect for tourists
• Accepts reservations
• Good for kids
• High chairs available
• Free parking lot
• Free street parking
• Dogs allowed outside

Opinions: This company has 92 reviews on Google My Business.

Average opinion: 4.5/5

👍 Reviews of Hustler's Tavern

Rachel N.

4/5

I thought the place was bigger from the pictures than it actually is, but it was very cozy. Their is a great atmosphere here as well, although it can be quite loud because of the size.
This was our second time here. The first time we didn't realize we needed reservations so we couldn't get in. Second time, had the reservations and it was no problem, we were seated promptly upon our arrival. The tables are a bit tight, but perfect and romantic for two.
We ordered the charcuterie board, excellent, and the candies brussel sprouts, recommended by a friend, and they definitely didn't disappoint!
We also ordered the deep dish pizza and man it was amazing!
Our waitress was phenomenal as well. Due to the table being quaint, after each dish she packed it up for us and put it in a to-go bag. We also wanted to try two of the pizzas and asked when ordering if she could only bring out half of each and automatically pack the second half. And she did! Marissa, I believe that was her name, thank you so much! You were great!
All in all, I will definitely order from here again, but more than likely takeout so we can spread out.

Scott

5/5

Immaculate experience everytime since the first time. It's hard to describe how the consistency in experience really accelerates this spot past the other in Lewiston and the Buffalo area. We always enjoy our visit here. The food is to die for - especially the pizza.

Lori B.

5/5

Everything about this restaurant was really impressive! As soon as you walk in the beautiful chandeliers and art create an inviting ambience. My husband and I ordered the brussel sprouts as an appetizer, which can be tough, but these were perfectly cooked and tender. For dinner we shared a custom pizza which consisted of pepperoni, mushrooms, and basil toppings. I could see the pizza dough being prepped and the pizza oven where it's cooked from where I was sitting. This was the BEST pizza I have ever had. I had the leftovers for breakfast the next day, and thoroughly enjoyed it both times! The drinks from the bar were also top notch. We had the Lion's Tail and Last Word. I highly recommend this restaurant to pizza and cocktail enthusiasts!

Mike P.

5/5

This review is only based takeout- online ordering was simple and provided pickup time, it was so simple, had the Detroit style pizza which was phenomenal. Brief moment that I had with customer service was outstanding. Next trip is to have dinner in the restaurant which seemed to have a cool vibe too

Mary

1/5

Food is... strange and quite overpriced compare to its quality.
I would especially mention Fresh Cut Truffle Fries and I really want to ask the chef if he ever tried to eat it himself (the whole bowl, uh?).
The space is very cramped, tight, narrow, uncomfortable. Tables "for two" can barely accommodate yourself, not your food. Or vice versa. Too bad. Instead of (supposed) romantic dinner you will play some sort of "items rearrangement game" 😂
Something like that relates to parking space (which is extremely limited with narrow lots). Be ready to discover that you can open car door just at one side. So you have to wait when your partner tries to pull the car out of the trap 🤣
This "game" makes your evening even more romantic 🤪 If you add some rain - you will have unforgettable experience, no doubt.
Bottom line: I would not make this mistake again visiting the place.

SharkByte 3.

5/5

Top notch pizzeria. It isn't just a place for pizza. Hustler's has a prohibition era vibe that fits in with the historic theme of the town of Lewiston. My wife and I had two cocktails, an Autumn margarita, and a traditional negroni. Both very good but a little strong. For food, we got two pizzas, one a Detroit style trational C&P. Quality was top notch, probably on par with Jay's Artisan in Kenmore. The other pizza was a Buffalo Chicken New York Style. Again excellent flavor, awesome crust and tasted just as good reheated as fresh. My only complaint is that it took about 35m to get the food, but boy oh boy was it worth it. A little pricey, but worth every penny.

Terri D.

4/5

Four star because limited menu. If your going to have a limited menu it better be good and it absolutely was delicious. Our server Catrina was shy but very friendly and attentive. Brussels spouts I highly recommend. Ny style mushroom pizza yummy. Capris salad a plenty maybe a drizzle of balsamic on top would be more tasty and would give it a nice presentation. Love love go check it out at least to try. It will surprise you.

FMG P.

5/5

Wow amazing pizza great salad definitely recommend the spicy crispy chicken Caesar salad. It was excellent. We had a Detroit style pizza and a New York style pizza with mushrooms delectable. They also have a wide range of wines to choose from. If you’re in the Lewiston area and looking for the best pizza around hustlers, Tavern is a place to be hustlers have an also has a lot of historical references so it could be a fun cool place to visit as well. If this review is helpful, feel free to tip on cash app. $Flamentco