Hallock's Cider Mill - Laurel, New York

Millie K.

There are a lot of pies at Hallock's Cider Mill, but the cider donuts and apple fritter were calling to us so we tried this instead and they were yummy. They also have a variety of ciders in their fridge. I enjoyed a cherry cider and hubby tried the natural pressed. Both were tasty. There are also a lot of preserves, crackers, and they have some vegetables and plants for sale. We had our snack on their picnic table at the end of their parking lot in the shade under their trees. Nice visit and would recommend a stop for pie, donuts, etc.

Connie H. K.

We are new to the North Fork and are SO EXCITED this little gem is right down the block! HANDS DOWN the BEST MANHATTAN CLAM CHOWDER!!!! It’s so perfect~ already packaged to go in the fridge~ you grab your quart or pint and you are all set!! Not only is it sooo flavorful, but it’s RICH with clams and a whole bunch of good stuff!!! Typically most chowders I find are all potato!! Not this one!! This last visit we also grabbed the asparagus (DELISH!) AND the key lime chocolate pie (OMG~~ and I’m not even a key lime fan~ my husband got it and WOW, I was surprised I loved it!). I’m including pics but just know the key lime pie is already half eaten…LOL!!! Def recommend you stop by~ as it’s conveniently located on Main Street and has SOOOO MUCH MORE~ I know they just reopened for the season so looking forward to seeing what else is in store!!!

Jenn P.

I have been coming here for years to get my pies and jam. They have the best baked goods around. I really would love love love their bread and pies. But honestly, they do have some exceptional jams and jellies as well and some cheese occasionally I like to grab when I stop by. It’s such a cute little farmstand shop that has all kinds of neat treats and local vegetables as well. They have some pickled products and a bunch of great pies and bakery items. It is really the place for pies in my opinion. I adore their raspberry peach pie when they have it and the key lime. Their triple crown jam is my favorite and they have the strawberry butter.. my oh my! A must try

Ashley Y.

THE best small market ever. My family stopped here looking for cider and found so much more - fresh produce, the cutest jams and salsas, homemade soups, and the most amazing pastries and baked goods anywhere on Long Island. The staff are all so friendly and make you feel so at home and every time you think you're done shopping, you find something new that you know you need... I didn't think it was possible but my family finished the huge jug of apple cider in 2 days and that's not even including the other drinks that we tried in smaller bottles on the way home. The fresh corn and other veggies made for the best additions to our dinner that night and the pastries were the perfect snacks on the way home and for dessert. The zucchini bread and chowder were our breakfast the next morning and we were already craving another trip back to Hallock's Cider Mill.

Mark L.

Nice fruit and vegetable stand with many other items for sale such as homemade pies. (The pies are just ordinary tasting) The staff is very friendly and accommodating.

Wook C.

Just like the name suggests, Apple cider is where this barkery / store shines. Go get their Apple Cider donuts - old fashion / cake-style. This is the quintessential, flagship donut that they make and it is absolutely marvelous. The Key Lime Pie was also phenomenal.

So then why not the 5-stars. They're simply just too expensive. $4 for a donut. This isn't like your world-class gourmet donuts we are talking about. This is your standard jelly donuts with not too soft dough and bread. Now the Applie cide donut is indeed special. But is it worth $4 a piece? Hmm... This store needs to get to their sense on price and they'll get their 5th star.

It is a fabulous place, a true crown jewel at the entrance of Norfolk.

Chris W.

Let me start by saying the soups are very, very good. The shrimp and corn chowder is my favorite, but the lobster bisque and both style clam chowder are all outstanding.
The deserts are great, the cakes and pies and donuts are all really good but the chocolate eclair might be the best you ever had.
They have all sorts of jelly, jam, and butters. The jalapeños jam is great. The pickles are great.
Everything is great. There are so many different things to try that you may not get to them all in a lifetime.

Lawrence G.

Best pie place ever.
Wayne Jr. and Sr. and staff are the friendliest people. We have been going there 9over 20 years and still the same.
Great Pies 🥧, breads 🥪, jellys and jams, cookies, cheeses, and many other stuff. The Horseradish is fresh and hot 🔥! He makes a apple crumb and other crumb coated pies. He makes a special Pumpkin crumb just for us!
Everything is fresh as we ordered a week in advance for all holidays {recommended to insure your pies} and yesterday when I went to get my order {12 pies and other stuff} my pumpkin crumb pies 🥧 were just coming out of the oven!
Talk about fresh! We will be back in the spring as they go on vacation after Christmas until Spring.
Well deserved time.
Enjoy Wayne and staff!