Braun Seafood Co. - Cutchogue, New York

A B.

Great outside area to grab seafood after a day at the beach or at the vineyards.

Lobster roll was the favorite. Scallops were delicious, but the risotto didn’t have much flavor.

We get takeout from here multiple times and started getting the calamari salad and adding scallops to that.

Favorites were the lobster roll, oysters, scallops, fried oysters, and the calamari salad (if you add scallops).

Cynthia K.

Nice people, cute clean atmosphere, good beer. The fries were practically perfect: nice and hot, crispy outside and delicious. The lobster roll was yummy with chunky lobster meat(& lots of it), it does have garlic on it which was different for me but some lemon squeezed over it helped cut the garlic.

Jackie J.

Stopped in and had a lobster roll with fries and claw and it was the BEST lobster roll I have ever had! I have had many in Maine and the cap and this one was out of this world. The bread they use for the roll is warm and buttery, just amazing!

Jacqueline C. D.

Staying in town for a vacation and picked up quality seafood to grill at home and have eaten here twice already with the lobster rolls and flounder sandwich. Very big portion sizes. Accommodated my two year old with a grilled cheese. Comfortable seating both inside and out.

Anne H.

We love the steamed whole lobsters, lobster roll, buffalo shrimp, and coleslaw. We liked the toasted almond cream cake ok and disliked the buffalo wings because they were pretty soft, we would have liked them more crisp.
The staff is helpful and kind. You can sit inside or outside. It’d be cool if they offered a garlic butter option for the steamed lobster as well! Definitely will be back.

Antoinette M. C.

In pre-Covid days in the summer i often came for the takeout and to sit under their tent. Usually had by a very tasty seafood sandwich. Returned this Sunday and sat with my daughter in their very clean and comfortable indoor sitting area. Order at the counter where menu is posted as well as a blackboard of specials. We ordered the fried calamari and seafood risotto.
The calamari was exceptional and truly the best I’ve ever had. The seafood risotto was not what a risotto is. It was not creamy and with two clams three mussels two thinly sliced pieces of chorizo and three shrimp placed on top. Go to an Italian or Spanish restaurant for a better creation with more Mediterranean flavor. I will come back for the calamari. They have in a can local wine. Pinot grigio was really good.
Service is good but wish they had given us a small receptacle for the shellfish.
December 2023
The above was their restaurant. For our Christmas Eve Italian dinner we bought several seafood to make Cioppino plus fish broth from their Market. It was very fresh and made a delicious dinner. See photo. Five star for fish market and four star for restaurant.
For New Years we purchased the freshest salmon and made a simple recipe using butter anchovies and capers. Another beautiful dinner.

March 2025. Took my daughter and her husband here. They live in Midwest and don’t get fresh fish like we do. In the small intimate dining area we had fried calamari, mussels (plump juicy and the best we had this season compared to other restaurants) and great French fries. Only We wished they served toasted bread with the mussels. The juice was so flavorful. Will ask the next visit. Which should be soon.

Michael T.

There are two stores here, one a fish market and the other, a sea food resturant and they are connected. The resturant was closed on Monday but the staff in the fish market let us walk in to take a look. Huge selection of fresh and frozen seafood.

Miguel B.

Highly recommended, I gave them my word that I was going to give a 5 stars review after helping me pack oyster,caviar and Sea Urchin I bought from them, lol, great customer service ,great seafood options I will definitely go back again and try their kitchen.