My Dad’s Cookies - Oceanside, New York

My Dad’s Cookies: A Delightful Treat

For those seeking exceptional food products and a truly memorable snacking experience, My Dad’s Cookies presents a compelling option. Located at Address: 3067 New St, Oceanside, NY 11572, and readily accessible via Phone: 62550056, this establishment has garnered a reputation for crafting high-quality, delicious cookies that cater to a wide range of palates. The company’s Website: mydadscookies.com serves as a convenient portal to explore their extensive selection and place orders. My Dad’s Cookies specializes in being a reliable Food products supplier, demonstrating a commitment to consistent quality and customer satisfaction.

A Focus on Premium Cookies

My Dad’s Cookies is renowned for its dedication to using premium ingredients and time-honored baking techniques. They've cultivated a loyal following, evidenced by the 33 reviews on Google My Business, each reflecting a distinct customer experience. The average opinion: 3.5/5 suggests a generally positive sentiment, although there’s an understandable desire for expansion of their product line. The company’s core offering revolves around a diverse array of cookies, each carefully crafted to deliver a perfect balance of flavor and texture.

Signature Varieties and Popular Choices

The cookies themselves are the heart of My Dad’s Cookies’ success. Customers consistently praise the cookies’ satisfying crunch and their avoidance of excessive sweetness – a characteristic that distinguishes them from many commercially produced alternatives. Several varieties stand out as particularly popular. The raspberry filled linzer tarts and the chocolate filled cookies (specifically the chocolata and chocolate fancy varieties) frequently receive rave reviews. Furthermore, there’s a significant demand for gluten-free options, with several customers specifically requesting the creation of chocolate dipped Italian cookies with the jelly in the middle – a testament to the company’s responsiveness to customer preferences. It’s clear that My Dad’s Cookies understands the importance of catering to diverse dietary needs and flavor profiles.

Convenient Amenities and Accessibility

My Dad’s Cookies prioritizes customer convenience. The location boasts a wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that individuals with mobility challenges can easily access the premises. Acceptance of various payment methods is also a key feature; Debit cards and Credit cards are readily accepted, streamlining the purchasing process. This commitment to accessibility underscores the company’s dedication to serving a broad customer base.

Key Features and Information

• Location: 3067 New St, Oceanside, NY 11572
• Phone: 62550056
• Website: mydadscookies.com
• Specialties: Food products supplier
• Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Debit cards, Credit cards

The company’s online presence, as evidenced by its website, provides a detailed catalog of its offerings. Visitors can browse through various cookie types, place orders for pickup or delivery (if available – details should be confirmed directly with the company), and learn more about the company’s story. The Google My Business profile offers valuable insights into store hours, contact information, and customer reviews, further enhancing the accessibility of this local business.

The positive feedback frequently mentioned centers around the cookies' texture—a desirable crispness that many consumers appreciate. It’s evident that My Dad’s Cookies has successfully identified a niche by offering a premium cookie experience that stands apart from mass-produced alternatives. The ongoing demand for specific variations, such as the gluten-free options and the requested Italian cookies, highlights the company’s willingness to adapt to customer requests and maintain a dynamic product selection. Essentially, My Dad’s Cookies represents a dedicated small business focused on providing high-quality, delicious cookies and fostering a positive customer relationship.

To further enhance the customer experience, the company could consider implementing a loyalty program or offering personalized recommendations based on past purchases. Expanding its delivery range would also be beneficial, allowing customers to enjoy My Dad’s Cookies from the comfort of their homes. Maintaining consistent quality and responsiveness to customer feedback will undoubtedly contribute to the continued success of this local favorite. The consistent praise for the cookies’ texture and balanced sweetness demonstrates a fundamental understanding of what customers seek in a premium cookie experience. The commitment to accessibility, combined with a diverse product offering, positions My Dad’s Cookies as a valuable addition to the Oceanside community.

👍 Reviews of My Dad’s Cookies

Peggy H.

5/5

I have purchased the 20 count assortment several times at my local Stop & Shop & really love these cookies! My favorites are the raspberry filled linzer tarts and the chocolate filled ones-chocolata & chocolate fancy. I love how crunchy they are and that they’re not too sweet. I will continue to buy them and hope they remain available locally. I would recommend them!

D

5/5

I am obsessed with these cookies. They are all so good and spot on for a gluten free cookie! Can you guys please make those chocolate dipped Italian cookies with the jelly in the middle !!!

rengel165

1/5

This is only a review for the Linzer cookies, but they are the worst gluten free baked goods I’ve ever had (diagnosed celiac 2014). Truly, these are tasteless circles of bland rice flour and tapioca, along with forgettable raspberry filling. They absolutely taste like processed garbage; a rip-off for $8.99! They sure do look good, but the book’s cover certainly belied my judgement…stay far away.

Re D. W. S. L.

5/5

These cookies are really good! With all my diet restrictions these have really have me a wide selection of sweets

margaret D.

5/5

First time user. excellent. Someone sent to me for bday. I just ate almost the entire box. You nailed it. Thank you Margaret

Ashley D.

1/5

I don't know how these cookies got into the supermarket but I had to review the label to see if they were also sugar free & flavor free. The square cookies were soggy and cardboard flavored. The chocolate center one tasted like disappointment. And the Jelly filled ones were like toilet paper tubes with Jelly in them. Definitely not worth the hefty price tag and won't buy again. I have had gluten free food that isn't terrible. These unfortunately are.

Belinda K.

1/5

Bought a small pack of the chocolate chip cookies at a grocery store in New Orleans. Absolutely awful. Tastes like play dough. Very dry and crumbly. I appreciate that companies are trying to produce gluten free products, but this company needs to try again.

Sophia L.

2/5

The cookies are really good but they screw you over on the price - they put 6 cookies in the top layer of the box, then try to hide the bottom layer and only put 3 cookies down there when 6 can obviously fit. Kind of a rip off. Wouldn’t mind paying $7 if there were actually 12 cookies per box instead of 9.