Old Factory Brewing Company - Cairo, New York

Mike E.

The creamy garlic jalapeño cheeseburger at Old Factory Brewing Company is a flavor explosion! The burger itself is juicy and cooked perfectly, and the jalapeño kick adds a nice touch of heat without being overpowering. The cheese is gooey and delicious, and it all comes together on a soft, fresh bun. If you like a little spice in your life, I highly recommend giving this burger a try.

TML

Mediocre food and a strange ordering process. Patrons order at the bar and pick up their own food. The fish and chips were soggy and undercooked and the mac and cheese was equally bland. Burger was a big sloppy mess. Oh, you can expect NYC prices.

Kim K.

Love the atmosphere, food is fantastic and more than enough food. With the choice of beer, you are sure to find something you will like.

I had to edit. You must try their specialty night. $3 Taco Thursday is delicious! The rueben egg rolls with thousand island sauce is so good. $6 Burger nights includes their delicious homemade fries.

You have to have a piece of their carrot cake. We take it home because we are so full. Look at the size of those pieces! You can see this is true homemade!
The real treat is the family that owns and runs it.

Look at those ribs!!!!! Can't beat those buffalo boneless wings either. The amount of those homemade fries could feed 4 or more! You really should stop in and say hi to Tim, Timothy, Donna and Shannon. Tell them Stephen and Kim sent you.😊

Laural K.

Loved this place! We were passing through from Delaware and stopped as a Harvest Host location. They were so helpful and saved us from a giant nightmare, when our gps stopped working they helped us get the maps reloaded! The food was amazing, the drinks were fantastic, the atmosphere was great, and the people there were the best! We can't recommend Old Factory Brewing Company enough. If you're in the area you have to come here or you're missing out!

Cherry D.

My husband and I stopped here for a quick drink after arriving in the Catskills for the weekend. We ordered a couple of flights, as well as the pulled pork nachos to munch on. They ran out of a couple of beers on tap and also didn’t have the onion rings, which was our first choice for an appetizer. Not off to a great start. Overall, I would say that the beers we tried were pretty mediocre. We visit A LOT of breweries and this one just didn’t impress us. When the pulled pork nachos came out, they were missing the pulled pork (see photo). To their credit, they fixed it right away after we brought it to their attention. Nevertheless, it seemed like an odd mistake to make. In the end, the nachos were okay, but nothing to write home about. 3 stars for the generally good service, even though we didn’t really enjoy the beer or food.

Michael J. B.

So I have been waiting forever to go here as I kept following them on social media. As I always say I am a home pit master and very picky. So I was disappointed with the food. We ordered a couple brisket sandwiches, the brisket was cooked well it just had no flavor on its own. Also ordered the Reuben eggrool and that was good. We ordered a side of fries with pulled pork and again tried the meat by itself and was bland to me. We had the regular burger and my son loved it. My wife ordered the same and had a different result. The chicken fingers were good. The cheese fries are with the nacho like cheese not a mozzarella. Now as far as beer I am no expert and I tried 5 different ones and not really my style. Overall wasn't as impressed as I wanted to be. The food was just ok for me.
The ambiance and service are awesome. The bar is to die for as they did an awesome job rehabbing the place.

Walter V. D.

I love the atmosphere of the Old Factory Brewing Company and, yes, the beer is amazing. I sampled five beers and was pleased with the unique flavor and characteristics of each. The tables and bar stools are generously spaced for social distancing. The tap counter is an impressive 66 feet long with a stunning design crafted by the Cornelison family. The building was refurbished and the interior created by the loving hands of the owners. Everything is fashioned using materials that have been recycled or repurposed down to the Irish Trinity and Irish Roses incorporated in the Tap Counter base. The kitchen had a soft opening on Saturday with burgers and fries. I can highly suggest having a delicious glass or two. Having a hard time deciding which brew to try? Start with a flight of four kinds and take home a growler of your favorite!

Lisa R.

This was a local brewery close to where we were staying. It was a nice place to stop for sure. The food was great and the beer was on point. The team jere was welcoming from the moment we arrived. The inside section is AC and it was a little cold for me but I’m always cold. We ended up making friends with some of the other patrons at the bar which was a nice surprise and just shows you how kind the people in the are really are. I would visit again if we’re in the area.